By the Valor Peak crew
Longmont, Colorado
What is a hot toddy?
A hot toddy is a warm mixed drink built from spirit, sweetener, citrus and hot water. It has been a cold weather favorite for centuries, and it is one of the simplest cocktails you can make at home. There is no shaker, no special glassware and no hard to find ingredient.
Because there are so few parts, the whiskey matters. The hot water opens up the aroma, so a toddy is a great way to taste how a spirit changes when it is warmed. Colorado nights in late October are the perfect excuse to try one.
What do you need to make a hot toddy?
You need a heatproof mug, a kettle and five ingredients. Two ounces of whiskey, about three quarters of an ounce of honey, half an ounce of fresh lemon juice and four to six ounces of hot water make one drink. For garnish, use a lemon wheel and a cinnamon stick, or press a few whole cloves into the lemon.
Fresh lemon makes a noticeable difference. Bottled juice tastes flat once it is warmed. Use a mild honey such as clover or wildflower so the whiskey can still come through.
How do you make a hot toddy step by step?
First, warm the mug by filling it with hot water for a minute, then pour it out. Add the honey and a splash of hot water and stir until the honey dissolves. Add the lemon juice and whiskey, then top with the rest of the hot water and stir again.
Taste before you garnish. If it is too sharp, add a little more honey. If it is too sweet, add a squeeze of lemon. Finish with the lemon wheel and spice. Do not use boiling water straight from the kettle, which can make the drink taste harsh. Let it rest for a few seconds first.
Which whiskey makes the best hot toddy?
Bourbon is the most popular choice because its vanilla and caramel notes pair naturally with honey. Our Bourbon gives a classic, rounded toddy, and our Wheated Bourbon #44 makes an especially soft version because wheat takes the place of rye in the grain bill.
American Single Malt gives a toddy with more bready, malty character, closer to the Scotch versions served in Scotland. Light Whiskey makes a delicate, lighter toddy that lets the lemon and spice lead. Read our guide to wheated bourbon if you want to understand why it drinks so softly.
“Cold nights call for something warm in the mug.”
What are good hot toddy variations?
Swap honey for maple syrup for a Colorado fall twist. Replace the hot water with hot black or chai tea for more depth. Add a slice of fresh ginger to the mug, or use apple cider in place of water for a cider toddy that tastes like the season.
For a party, batch the whiskey, honey and lemon in advance and keep hot water in an insulated carafe. Guests can build their own in about thirty seconds.
Why does a hot toddy feel so good on a cold night?
Part of it is simple warmth. A hot mug in your hands and steam rising off the glass signal comfort before the first sip. The aroma also does a lot of work. Warm liquid releases more of a spirit's scent, so honey, lemon, spice and whiskey all reach you at once.
There is also ritual. Making a toddy takes a few minutes and a little attention, which makes it a natural way to close a long day. Many people keep it as a once in a while winter treat rather than an everyday drink, and that is part of the charm.
What mistakes should you avoid?
The most common mistake is too much honey. Start with less, since you can always add more. The second is old lemon juice, which turns bitter when warmed. The third is pouring too much whiskey. A toddy should taste balanced and warming, not hot with alcohol.
Finally, watch the temperature. A drink that is too hot to sip loses its charm quickly, and boiling water mutes the whiskey. Let the kettle rest, warm the mug, and serve the toddy hot but drinkable.
Where can you try whiskey before choosing a bottle?
The easiest way is a tasting flight. At our Longmont tasting room you can try the lineup side by side, then pick the bottle you want for winter toddies. Our bartenders are happy to talk through which spirit fits your taste.
What else should you know?
What is the ratio for a hot toddy?
A good starting point is two ounces of whiskey, three quarters of an ounce of honey, half an ounce of lemon juice and four to six ounces of hot water. Adjust honey and lemon to taste.
Can you make a hot toddy with bourbon?
Yes. Bourbon is the most common choice because its vanilla and caramel notes pair well with honey.
Should the water be boiling?
Use water just off the boil. Boiling water can make the drink taste harsh and can dull the whiskey's aroma.
Can I make a hot toddy without alcohol?
Yes. Use strong black tea or apple cider in place of whiskey for a warm, non-alcoholic version.
What garnish goes with a hot toddy?
A lemon wheel with a cinnamon stick or a few whole cloves is classic. Star anise or a slice of ginger also work.

